What is Target's P/E ratio compared to Costco and Walmart?

Target's P/E is around 15, while Costco's is 40 and Walmart's is 25.

Is splitting investment between Costco and Walmart better than buying Target?

It depends on investment horizon; Target may offer higher rebound but more risk, while Costco and Walmart are more stable.

Better Buy: Target at an All-Time High or a 50/50 Split of Costco and Walmart?

Target (TGT) is trading about 50% below its all-time high and at a massive discount to peers Costco (COST) and Walmart (WMT). This analysis explores which is the better buy.

July 4, 2026

2 min read

Source: Motley Fool

Key Numbers

target all time high

50% below

target peers discount

massive

In an analysis from Motley Fool, an investment question is posed: Is it better to buy Target (TGT) at its low, or split investment equally between Costco (COST) and Walmart (WMT)?

Rating Change

No official rating change, but the analysis compares the two options based on current market valuation.

Analyst Rationale

Target (TGT): Trading about 50% below its all-time high, appearing undervalued vs. peers. P/E ratio ~15 vs. Costco's 40 and Walmart's 25.
Costco (COST): Strong customer loyalty and subscription model, but high valuation.
Walmart (WMT): Retail leader with e-commerce investments, but slower growth.

Context

Target has underperformed due to weak discretionary spending, while Costco and Walmart benefited from essential goods focus. However, the analyst believes Target's discount may be overdone.

Conclusion

Choice depends on investment horizon and risk tolerance. Target offers higher rebound potential but with more risk; Costco and Walmart are more stable but expensive. No buy/sell recommendation, just an objective comparison.

Frequently Asked Questions

Due to weak consumer spending on discretionary goods, impacting Target's sales compared to peers focused on essentials.

Found this useful? Share it

This article was rewritten in Wrqti's editorial style based on information from the original source above. Content is informational only — not investment advice.